Mustards and sauces
not your average condiment

Pick 3 Mix and Match Bundle
$24.95 or subscribe and save 15%

GAME DAY BUNDLE
$24.95 or subscribe and save 15%

HORSERADISH SAUCE
Starting at $24.95 or subscribe and save 15%

SPICY BROWN MUSTARD
Starting at $24.95 or subscribe and save 15%
where family, flavor
and the rockies meet
Our specialty mustards aren’t just condiments—they’re culinary companions that turn every meal into a masterpiece. Whether you’re grilling, dipping, or spreading, our mustards are the secret ingredient that transforms your dishes into unforgettable culinary adventures.
our products
We make the best sauces in town!
McCaffrey Rocky Mountain Sauces have earned a reputation as the best in town, and for good reason. Crafted with locally sourced ingredients and inspired by bold, mountain flavors, each sauce delivers a perfect balance of heat, sweetness, and tang that elevates any dish. Whether you’re firing up the grill or spicing up a weekday dinner, McCaffrey’s offers a flavor-packed punch that locals can’t get enough of. With a loyal following and rave reviews from foodies and chefs alike, it’s no surprise that McCaffrey Rocky Mountain Sauces are considered the gold standard in town.
what our fans say!
"What a mustard, makes the best deviled eggs and is a fantastic spicy Brown Mustard, goes well with roast beef sandwiches, hot dogs of every type, even bratwurst. Spicy but not hot!"
Don
"McCaffrey Brands' yellow mustard has been praised for its smooth, tangy flavor and ability to enhance various dishes, including hot dogs, burgers, and sandwiches. The mustard is described as a kitchen essential that elevates everyday meals."
"McCaffrey's Horseradish Sauce has customers praising its zesty flavor, smooth texture, and versatility in various dishes. It's often described as a good balance of creamy and spicy, making it a favorite for sandwiches, dips, marinades, and salad dressings. Some users also appreciate its fresh, ground horseradish taste, which they find superior to other brands."